SullysBlog

Domain investing tips, strategies, and industry insights

Advertisement
Grit Brokerage
Advertisement
Infinite Designs, Inc.
Advertisement
NotRenewing.com
What 1,000+ Domain Sales Taught Me About What Buyers Actually Want

What 1,000+ Domain Sales Taught Me About What Buyers Actually Want

•


Back in August, I wrote an article for NamePros about what the first 500 sales on NotRenewing.com taught me about domain liquidity.

At the time, I had 22,112 listings to analyze. I figured another 500 sales would help confirm some of the patterns I was seeing. back then.

We've now more than doubled that number, and a few things have changed.

As of November 16, NotRenewing has recorded 1,204 paid purchases, with 1,133 completed sales. Those sales came from 52,479 listings across 123 different extensions. Every completed sale to that point was at $99.

Having a fixed price makes the data interesting and there's no negotiating, no wondering whether a seller will accept an offer, and no guessing what someone might pay. Buyers either want the name at $99 or they don't.

Here's is how I read the latest data

When I wrote the first article, roughly one out of every 43 domains listed had sold. Today, it's one in 46. Not a huge change at the micro level. The sell-through rate actually slipped a little, from 2.34% to 2.2%, even though the number of listings more than doubled.

I was hoping that as the marketplace grew, we'd see more activity relative to the inventory. We're certainly seeing more sales, but the percentage of names selling hasn't increased.

There have now been 5,345 domains listed on NotRenewing that eventually expired without finding a $99 buyer.

Think about that for a minute.

Those owners were willing to take $99 rather than renew the names, and the buyers still weren't there.

Of course, not every listing gets equal exposure. In fact, 2,430 of the domains currently listed have never received a single view. That's something I need to improve on my end. Although it is in part fueled by what buyers are searching for.

But it also raises a question domain investors should be asking themselves.

If you can't find a buyer for a name at $99, how confident should you be that someone will eventually pay $2,500 for it? I'm not saying it can't happen. I've seen stranger things. I'm saying the lack of demand should probably factor into your renewal decisions.

One of the biggest surprises in the first 500 sales was how much business came from a relatively small group of buyers.

At that point, ten buyers accounted for 51% of sales. That number has dropped to 42.5%.

It's still a significant concentration, but it's moving in the right direction. There are now 224 distinct buyers, and the marketplace is becoming less dependent on a handful of individuals.

What's interesting is that repeat buyers still account for more than 90% of completed sales.

Once someone buys a domain through NotRenewing, there's a good chance they'll buy another.

Some are buying several names a week. Others show up, buy a few, disappear for a while, and then return. Some know what they are looking for and leverage the keyword alerts in order to get the jump on new names.

I think that says something about the type of buyer the marketplace attracts. These aren't necessarily people looking for the perfect name for a business they're launching. Many are domain investors looking for inventory they believe they can resell.

And they're selective. They might look at hundreds of names before finding one worth buying.

In the original article, nearly 55% of sales happened within 24 hours of a domain being listed.

That has dropped to 47.2%.The median time to purchase has increased from 21.6 hours to 28.2 hours. If I isolate the sales that happened after the first 500, the change is even more noticeable. Only 40.9% sold during the first day.

Some names still disappear almost immediately. Meyer.si sold five minutes after being listed.

Others take considerably longer.

IndependentBots.com, IndependentRobot.com, and IndependentRobots.com all sold to the same buyer after 202 days.

The larger buyers still move quickly. The six most active buyers purchase nearly 70% of their domains during the first day. Everyone else is closer to 37%.

So the early activity is heavily influenced by a relatively small number of aggressive buyers. But, that doesn't mean a domain that survives the first day has no chance. It means there are different types of buyers shopping at different speeds.

Here's something I didn't see coming.

When I first analyzed the sales, .com represented about 71% of everything sold. Today, that number is down to 57.8%. And a big reason is .si.

During September, 35 .si domains sold. In October, that number jumped to 171, representing nearly 61% of all completed sales that month. Across the marketplace, 253 .si domains have sold from 2,406 listings. That's a 10.5% sell-through rate.Compare that with .com, which accounts for roughly 80% of listings but has a sell-through rate of only 1.6%.

Now, before anyone runs out to register 500 .si domains, there's something worth mentioning.

The September .si listings have sold through at 27.5%. The October listings are at 10.5%, and November's newer listings are at 3.6%.

The newer inventory hasn't had as much time to sell, but those numbers certainly don't establish that October's buying activity will continue.

What I find more interesting is the buyers themselves. There have been 71 buyers of .si domains and 133 buyers of .com domains. Only 25 have purchased both.

That's a pretty different audience.

It's another reminder that we tend to discuss the domain aftermarket as though everyone is looking for the same thing.

They aren't.

Some things haven't changed.

Domains with three characters or fewer have a 9.6% sell-through rate. Names with thirteen or more characters are at 1.2%.

That's an eightfold difference. But the length numbers aren't nearly as interesting to me as the dictionary word numbers.

Single dictionary words now account for 19.1% of completed sales, up from about 14% when I did the first analysis.

They've sold through at 8.6%, compared with 1.8% for everything else.

That's a substantial difference.

A recognizable word doesn't need much explaining. Someone sees it, understands it, and can decide whether it fits their investment strategy.

I've always liked good dictionary words, but the data reinforces why they're worth paying attention to, even in extensions other than .com.

Of course, there are plenty of awful dictionary-word combinations. Having a real word doesn't automatically make the domain valuable. But it's one of the clearest signals in the numbers.

The first analysis showed that domains at least ten years old were about 3.4 times more likely to sell than younger names. That advantage has dropped to 2.1 times. The median age of a sold domain has also fallen from 8.5 years to five years.

At first glance, you might think buyers are becoming less interested in older domains. But that's not quite what's happening.

The explosion of .si sales introduced a large number of recently registered domains into the completed sales data.

Remove .si from the calculation, and older domains still have roughly a threefold advantage.

So I haven't changed my opinion on age.

An older registration can be a useful clue, particularly when looking through portfolios that have been held for years. But nobody should be buying a bad domain simply because it was registered in 2002.

Buyers aren't waiting until the last minute and this is one finding that has become more convincing.

When I wrote the first article, the median amount of registration time remaining on a purchased domain was 135 days. It's now 212 days.

More than 54% of completed sales with reliable expiration dates involved domains that still had at least six months left before expiration.

That's not what you might expect from a marketplace built around domains owners aren't planning to renew.

It tells me buyers aren't necessarily looking for names that are about to drop. They're looking for names they want at a price they're comfortable paying.

The expiration date is important to the seller. It isn't necessarily important to the buyer.

For domain owners considering NotRenewing, there's a lesson here. You don't have to wait until the final weeks of registration to give a name a chance to sell.

I wanted to look at some of the popular keywords being listed because AI-related names continue to attract a lot of attention.I found that even at $99, popular kepwords don't guarantee demand.

There have been 2,149 listed domains beginning or ending with "ai." Only 24 have sold.

That's a 1.1% sell-through rate, about half the marketplace average.

Meanwhile, domains containing "agent" as a prefix or suffix have sold through at 2.72 times the marketplace rate, and "bot" at about twice the rate.

There are also 244 names using "crypto" and 205 using "shop" in the same keyword positions that haven't produced a single sale.

These are keyword-specific measurements, not valuations of entire industries, but the differences are worth looking at.

Registering a name because the keyword is popular isn't the same as registering a name someone wants.

There's a lot of speculation in the domain business. These numbers are a useful reminder that the market doesn't always share our enthusiasm.

I started NotRenewing to give domain owners an alternative to letting names expire without attempting one last sale. It was an idea collecting dust that I finally pulled the trigger on in March of this year.

I expected to learn something about what sells, lower price points, renewals, and more. What I really didn't expect was how much I'd learn about the buyers themselves.

They come back. They move at different speeds. They have different philosophies. Some gravitate toward .com, while others are actively buying alternative extensions. They generally favor shorter names and recognizable words, but there's no formula that guarantees a sale or excludes any name.

Also, simply adding more inventory doesn't improve the odds of a sale.

52,479 listings have generated just over 86,000 listing views in total. That's an average of only 1.6 views per listing.

Clearly, getting the right names in front of the right buyers is just as important as finding more names to list.

One thing I want to be careful about is applying these results to the entire domain market. This is a $99 marketplace where owners are generally trying to sell names they don't intend to renew. It's not a measure of how a premium portfolio will perform at retail prices.

Still, I think there's value in seeing what happens when thousands of domain owners offer their inventory at the same price.

We've now watched buyers make more than a thousand successful purchasing decisions without needing to negotiate.

And perhaps the most useful lesson is that what we think a domain should be worth has very little to do with whether someone actually wants to buy it.

I'll keep watching what the next thousand sales tell us.

Data through November 16, 2026. The analysis includes 52,479 listings, 1,204 paid purchases and 1,133 completed sales. I am the founder of NotRenewing.com.

Share:

0 Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email will not be published.

No comments yet.

Be the first to share your thoughts!