Domain investors think about acquisitions, renewals, pricing, and sales all day. We track expiration dates, compare registrars, tweak landing pages, and argue with ourselves about which names deserve another year. Then there's the one question almost nobody spends time on.
What happens to our domains when we die?
A portfolio doesn't work like a bank account or a house. Your family probably knows where you bank and who holds the mortgage. They may have no idea how many domains you own, where they're registered, or what any of them are worth. And even if they know the portfolio exists, that doesn't mean they can get to it.
The industry got a hard lesson in this back in 2013, when Igal Lichtman died. Most of us knew him as Mrs Jello. He was a successful software entrepreneur, an investor, and the owner of a serious domain portfolio.
🔥 Check out NotRenewing.com
Browse expiring and dropping domains — all at a flat $99. No auctions, no negotiations.
Lichtman died of cancer on February 18, 2013. Right around that time, three domains owned by Mrs Jello LLC expired and went to auction. Vegans.com sold for $48,000. Vodka.net brought $20,000. Penis.net went for $5,015.
That's more than $73,000, and coverage at the time reported that none of it went to his family. It went to the auction platforms and registrars. And those were just the expired names anyone had spotted. There may have been more. Once the story broke, the registrars involved did step up, freezing the remaining auctions and renewing the names still in the delete cycle so the family could decide what to do with them. But the ones already sold were gone.
To be fair, we shouldn't draw a straight line from his death to the expirations. Domains don't drop overnight, and those names were probably already deep in the cycle while he was sick. Still, the timing showed how fast valuable digital assets can walk out the door.
There's no deed sitting in a safe deposit box for a domain. Control comes down to a registrar account, an email address, a password, and a credit card. If nobody can get into the email, the renewal notices go unread. If the card on file gets canceled after the owner dies, auto-renew quietly fails. If two-factor authentication points to the owner's phone, even someone holding the password may be locked out.
Then there's the value problem. A family member might recognize that Cars.com is worth something. Would that same person see the value in a two-word industry name, a short acronym, or an aged domain with real traffic and backlinks? Probably not. Without guidance, they might let the good names expire, take the first lowball offer that shows up, or keep renewing a few thousand weak names for years because they can't tell the keepers from the junk.
Every serious investor should have a simple succession plan. It should list every registrar you use, the email tied to each account, and how to get in. It should say where the portfolio records live and how the renewals get paid.
It should also name someone who actually understands domains. Another investor, a broker, an attorney who knows digital assets, a trusted industry contact. Your family shouldn't have to learn this business while they're dealing with everything else that follows a death.
A spreadsheet helps, but it needs to be more than a list of names. Flag the strongest domains. Note rough wholesale and retail values, open inquiries, payment plans, and any name that absolutely can't be allowed to drop.
And put the domains in a will, a trust, or a business succession plan. The legal treatment varies, so talk to an estate planning attorney instead of taping a note next to the computer.
I've always called domains digital real estate. The comparison holds up for scarcity and value, but it falls apart at inheritance. A house can't disappear because nobody renewed it. A domain can.
We put years into building these portfolios. A few hours spent writing down what you own, and what should happen to it, might be the best renewal decision you ever make.